Sharp-tuned filter-combiner for combining adjacent TV channels

ABSTRACT

A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels is presented herein. The combiner has two inputs that respectively receive an NTSC combined visual and aural signal and a DTV signal wherein the NTSC signal and the DTV signal are in adjacent channels. The DTV signal is of greater frequency than the NTSC signal. A combined output signal is provided at an output of the combiner. The combiner has sharp tuned filtering interposed between the inputs and the output and tuned to pass the DTV signal while reflecting the NTSC signal such that the passed DTV signal and the reflected NTSC signal combine as the combined output signal.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/195,238 filed Apr. 7, 2000 and U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/236,225 filed Sep. 28, 2000.

BACKGROUND AND FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to transmitting television signals and, more particularly, to combining adjacent television channels such as two adjacent digital signals (DTV) or the combining of an analog signal (NTSC) with an adjacent digital signal (DTV).

DESCRIPTION OF THE PRIOR ART

Television signals have traditionally been broadcast in an analog format known as NTSC. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is now permitting a new digital format known as DTV. The digital format is presently in operation and the FCC has provided a transitional period until the year 2006 during which the NTSC signals and the DTV signals will both be transmitted. Thus, a station will simulcast both an NTSC signal and a DTV signal. It is understood that the FCC has allocated frequency bands or channels wherein an NTSC signal will be adjacent a DTV signal and also that a DTV signal will be adjacent to another DTV signal. In the United States, the channels are all 6 MHz wide, whereas in other parts of the world the channels are 6-8 MHz wide. The discussion presented herein is specifically directed to channels that are 6 MHz wide although it is to be understood that the discussion may be similar for channels that are up to 8 MHz wide.

When a DTV allocation is one channel below an NTSC channel, this is referred to as the N−1 case. When the DTV allocation is one channel above an NTSC channel, this is referred to as the N+1 case.

To prevent adjacent channels from interfering with each other, it has been known in the past to employ bandpass filters and hybrid couplers, simply referred to herein as hybrids, to form bandpass filter-combiners. Bandpass filter-combiners are described in a four page article entitled, Adjacent Channel Combining for N+1 DTV Channel Allocations, in the ADC Technical News Publication, dated Jul. 30, 1998 published by ADC Telecommunications, Inc. FIG. 1 herein is based on FIG. 1 in that publication and presents a bandpass filter-combiner employing a pair of bandpass filters 10 and 12 interposed between hybrids 14 and 16. One of the input ports of hybrid 14 is coupled to a reject load 18 and the other input receives an RF signal A. Another RF signal B is supplied to a port on filter 16. The bandpass filters 10 and 12 are tuned to pass signal A but reflect signal B. Consequently, signal A enters the left side port of hybrid 14 and the signal splits into portions which pass through the bandpass filters 10 and 12 and thence into the hybrid 16 and combine with signal B. Signal B entered the hybrid and then split with portions reflecting off the bandpass filters 10 and 12 and returning into the hybrid to combine with signal A to provide a combined signal A+B at an output port of hybrid 16. The article points out that the filter-combiner of FIG. 1 is not practical for use in an N+1 case wherein the DTV channel is above the NTSC channel. This is because the aural carrier in the N+1 case is only 0.25 MHz away from the upper channel edge, and may have sidebands up to 120 kHz away. Thus, the guard band is very small.

The ADC article proposes a design for the N+1 case and this takes the form shown herein at FIG. 2 which is based on FIG. 5 in the ADC article. FIG. 2 herein shows a constant impedance filter-combiner 20 in combination with a notch diplexer 22. The constant impedance filter-combiner 20 is based on that illustrated herein at FIG. 1 and, consequently, like components are identified with like character references. Signal A is replaced with a DTV signal and signal B is replaced with a VISUAL signal from an NTSC signal. The AURAL signal has been removed and, as will be seen, is re-inserted downstream. The bandpass filters 10 and 12 are tuned to pass the DTV signal and reflect the VISUAL signal. The output port will provide a combined signal including the DTV signal and the VISUAL signal. This signal is then supplied to the notched diplexer where the AURAL signal is re-inserted. The notched diplexer is tuned to reject or reflect the AURAL signal and to pass the combined DTV and VISUAL signals obtained from the filter-combiner 20. The notched diplexer includes a left hybrid 24 having an input port for receiving the combined signal from the filter-combiner 20 and another input port connected to a load 26. The notched diplexer includes a pair of aural notch filters 28 and 30 that extend from the left hybrid 24 to a right hybrid 32. The AURAL signal is supplied to a port 34 of hybrid 32 and the AURAL signal is then split and portions reflect back from filters 28 and 30 so that the AURAL signal combines with the DTV and VISUAL signals and the combined signal appears at an output port 36 for application to an antenna 38. It is to be noted that most notched diplexers also include −3.58 MHz traps in series with the AURAL notched filters, such as filters 28 and 30 in FIG. 2, to provide attenuation of unwanted color difference products in the lower sideband. For simplicity, such traps have not been included in FIG. 2.

By splitting the NTSC signal into its VISUAL and AURAL components, the prior art presented in FIG. 2 requires that the AURAL signal be added down stream. Consequently, in order to handle the N+1 case, this type of prior art requires a circuit having three inputs for receiving the DTV, VISUAL, and AURAL signals. Additionally, this circuit requires the use of four hybrids 14, 16, 24 and 32. It is desirable to reduce the cost of the equipment needed to handle an N+1 case.

Attention is now directed to FIG. 3 which illustrates another prior art circuit for handling the N+1 case. This circuit includes only two hybrids 40 and 42 as opposed to the four hybrids employed in the circuit of FIG. 2. The left hybrid 40 has an input port connected to a load 41 and a second input port that receives a DTV signal by way of a power amplifier 44. The DTV signal splits as it enters the hybrid 40 and a portion of it is passed by a DTV bandpass filter 46 and another portion is passed by a DTV bandpass filter 48. These DTV portions are passed by AURAL notches 50 and 52 and then enter the right hybrid 42. An NTSC signal that includes both AURAL and VISUAL components is supplied to a port on the right side of hybrid 42 and these signals split in the hybrid and the AURAL portions are reflected from the AURAL notches 50 and 52 and are passed back through the hybrid and recombined and are applied to an antenna 60. The VISUAL portions of the NTSC signal pass through the AURAL notch cavities of the AURAL notches 50 and 52 and are reflected by the DTV bandpass filters 46 and 48 and return through the AURAL notches 50 and 52 and thence into the right hybrid 42 and combine with the DTV and AURAL signals and supplied to the antenna 60. Whereas the circuit of FIG. 3 only has two hybrids, it is to be noted that the NTSC VISUAL signal passes over the AURAL notches twice during the operation adding a heat burden to the AURAL cavities. Any temperature drifting will cause performance parameters to fall outside the equalization set up because there is no tracking adaptive system in NTSC. Also, it is to be noted that a notch diplexer type combiner as shown in FIG. 3 results in reduced DTV to NTSC chroma isolation. Additionally, the AURAL notch causes equalization problems for the transmitter system because the notched bandwidth can cut back into the NTSC chroma region which causes additional high frequency video equalization adjustments.

From the foregoing discussion of the prior art circuits of FIGS. 1, 2 and 3, it is seen that an improvement is needed in the bandpass filters that are employed in these combiners. A more sharply tuned filter is needed that will pass the DTV signal for a particular channel while reflecting all other frequencies including an adjacent channel NTSC signal or an adjacent channel DTV signal. The filter should exhibit an amplitude response within a mandated mask (such as the FCC mandated mask). Such a sharply tuned filter can be used as a stand alone filter having deep levels of IMD sideband rejection at the channel edges for additional FCC mask suppression. This enhances transmitter performance so that the transmitter power may be increased substantially while meeting the requirements of the FCC mandated mask.

In addition to operating as a stand alone mask filter resulting in power enhancement, such sharply tuned filters may be employed in a constant impedance filter-combiner without the need for notched filters for the AURAL carrier signal and, hence, such a combiner may be employed in the N+1 case as well as in the N−1 case as well as for adjacent channel DTV signals.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

In accordance with one aspect of the present invention, an apparatus is provided for combining television signals. The combiner has two inputs for respectively receiving an NTSC signal, including both VISUAL and AURAL components, and a DTV signal wherein the NTSC signal and the DTV signal are in adjacent channels with the DTV signal being of greater frequency than the NTSC signal. The combiner has sharply tuned filtering. The filtering is tuned for passing the DTV signal while reflecting the NTSC signal and such that the passed DTV signal and the reflected NTSC signal combine as a combined output signal.

In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, the combiner includes first and second hybrids and first and second sharp tuned filters. The filters are tuned to pass only the DTV signal while reflecting the NTSC signal.

In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, the signal combiner has two inputs for respectively receiving a first DTV signal and a second DTV signal wherein the TV signals are of different frequencies and in adjacent channels. The combiner has sharply tuned filtering such that the first DTV signal is passed while the second DTV signal is reflected. The passed and reflected signals combine to provide a combined output signal.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The foregoing and other objects and advantages of the present invention will become more readily apparent from the following as taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein:

FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustration of a bandpass filter-combiner in accordance with the prior art;

FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustration of another bandpass filter-combiner in combination with a notch diplexer in accordance with the prior art;

FIG. 3 is a notch type combiner also in accordance with the prior art;

FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustration of a sharp tuned filter constructed in accordance with the present invention and illustrated in combination with an amplifier and an antenna;

FIG. 5 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency and illustrating typical filter specifications for amplitude response and also including the FCC mask and the sharp tuned filter mask herein;

FIG. 6 is a graphical illustration of time in nanoseconds versus frequency and illustrating typical filter specifications with respect to group delay;

FIG. 7 illustrates an embodiment of the invention herein employing two sharply tuned filters and two hybrids employed for supplying an amplified DTV signal to an antenna for broadcasting;

FIG. 8 is a block diagram illustration of an embodiment of the invention herein for performing adjacent channel combining of an NTSC signal and a DTV signal in an N+1 case or an N−1 case;

FIG. 9 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the operation of the embodiment in FIG. 8 for adjacent NTSC and DTV channels in the N+1 case;

FIG. 10 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the operation of the embodiment in FIG. 8 for adjacent NTSC and DTV channels in the N−1 case;

FIG. 11 is similar to that of FIG. 8 but employed for combining adjacent channel DTV signals;

FIG. 12 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the operation of the circuitry in FIG. 11 with respect to adjacent DTV channels;

FIG. 13 is another embodiment of the invention employing adaptive equalization RF sample feedback;

FIG. 14 is another embodiment of the invention similar to that as illustrated in FIG. 13, but including additional features;

FIG. 15 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency that show the lower adjacent channel response in an N+1 case;

FIG. 16 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency illustrating the DTV bandpass amplitude response;

FIG. 17 is a graphical illustration of time in nanoseconds with respect to frequency illustrating the group delay response of the sharp tuned filter;

FIG. 18 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the video response of the filter herein;

FIG. 19 is a graphical illustration of time in nanoseconds with respect to frequency illustrating the video group delay of the sharply tuned filter the reduction in the equalization requirement of the transmitter;

FIG. 20 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing improved isolation;

FIG. 21 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency illustrating the monaural amplitude response of a sharp tuned filter;

FIG. 22 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing a stereo signal amplitude response of the filter herein;

FIG. 23 is a graphical illustration of time with respect to frequency showing a stereo signal group delay response of the filter herein;

FIG. 24 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing a typical transmitter spectral spread of a DTV signal;

FIG. 25 is a graphical illustration similar to that of FIG. 24 but showing the 0.5 MHz FCC integrated power zone;

FIG. 26 is a graphical illustration similar to that of FIGS. 23 and 24 but illustrating the operation of a transmitter employing a sharp tuned filter constructed in accordance with the invention herein;

FIG. 27 is similar to FIGS. 24-26 but illustrating an enhanced high power operation of a transmitter without a sharp tuned filter and with a sharp tuned filter constructed in accordance with the filter described herein;

FIG. 28 is a block diagram similar to FIG. 4 but including a feedback path and an exciter;

FIG. 29 is an elevational view illustrating a waveguide that may be employed in practicing the invention herein;

FIG. 30 is a view taken along line 30-30 looking in the direction of the arrows in FIG. 29 and illustrating the configuration of the input port of the waveguide;

FIG. 31 is a view taken along line 31-31 looking in the direction of the arrows in FIG. 29 illustrating an iris plate;

FIG. 32 is a view taken along line 32-32 looking in the direction of the arrows in FIG. 29 illustrating another iris plate;

FIG. 33 is a view taken along line 33-33 looking in the direction of the arrows in FIG. 29 and showing a still further iris plate;

FIG. 34 is an enlarged perspective view of the filter that also illustrates adjustment screws (probes); and

FIG. 35 is a sectional view showing iris plate 111.

DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

Reference is now made to FIG. 4 which illustrates a sharp tuned filter (STF) 100 constructed in accordance with the present invention and which is illustrated as having a single input port 101 and a single output port 102. The input port is illustrated as being connected to the output of an amplifier 104 which, for example, may receive and amplify a digital DTV signal for a particular channel, such as channel 10. The DTV signal is applied to the sharp tuned filter 100 which is tuned to pass only signals in this channel, i.e. channel 10 in the example being described. The passed DTV signal is then provided at the output port 102 and forwarded to a load, such as an antenna 106 for broadcasting purposes.

It is to be understood that the load may take a form other than an antenna. The filter 100 may take various forms such as a length of coaxial cable or a wave guide. The structural configuration may take these or other forms so long as the filter complies with the specifications noted below and given with reference to the graphical illustrations in FIGS. 5 and 6. For example, the filter 100 may take the form of waveguide 101 shown in FIGS. 29-33. This waveguide is a hollow cylinder constructed of suitable conductive metal, such as aluminum, copper or steel. The waveguide may have multiple cavities, such as cavities 103, 105 and 107 defined by iris plates 111, 113, and 115. The iris plates and the three sections of the waveguide may be held together as with welding or bolt and nut arrangements. The waveguide has an input port 117 and an output port. The input port is of rectangular shape, as indicated at FIG. 30. The iris plates have iris openings of various shapes. For example, the iris opening in plate 111 is a cross 121 as shown in FIG. 31. The iris opening in plate 113 is a horizontal slot M45 as shown in FIG. 32. The iris opening in plate 115 is a vertical slot M60. As best shown in FIGS. 34, 35, the waveguide 101 also has mode resonance screws i-vi and mode coupling screws M12, M34 and M56 that protrude into the cavities. These screws (or probes) are made of metal, such as copper, and extend into the cavities by various amounts, such as in the range from 0.25 inch to 0.50 inch for a circular waveguide having an inner diameter on the order of 20.0 inches. Note that cavity 103 is for mode resonance numbers 1, 2 and that cavity 105 is for mode resonance numbers 3, 4 and that cavity 107 is for mode resonance numbers 5, 6. The cross 121 includes slot M14 that couples resonances 1 and 4 and slot M23 that couples resonances 2 and 3. The horizontal slot M45 couples resonances 4 and 5.

The filter sections are realized thorough distributed capacitances and inductances through the use of the circular waveguide cavity sections separated by conductive iris plates. The size of the cavities is such that two modes (such as modes 1, 2 or 3, 4 or 5, 6) are allowed to propagate through the waveguide (as opposed to the propagation of only the dominant mode).

The filter is tuned during construction to comply with the specifications set forth in FIGS. 5 and 6. The tuning includes varying the length and inner diameter of the waveguide and varying the shape and size of the iris openings and the orientation of the openings relative to each other. The waveguide may be on the order of 6 feet in length and about 20 inches in inner diameter. Additional tuning during filter construction involves adjusting the screws (probes) i-vi and M12, M34 and M56. For example a first adjustment may be made as to the depth that these screws protrude into the waveguide cavities. Then a test may be made by applying RF energy of the frequency channel of interest and then a determination is made with suitable meters (such as a spectrum analyzer) as to the filter response relative to the FCC mask. This step may be repeated until the response meets the specifications herein. The adjustment of the mode resonance screws i-vi change the resonant frequency in the associated cavity. The filter bandwidth is changed by adjusting the three mode coupling screws M12, M34 and M56. Deeper screw penetration provides greater mode coupling. This increases filter bandwidth. The opposite adjustment decreases filter bandwidth.

In FIG. 5 there is illustrated, in dotted lines, the FCC mask 110 for DTV signals sometimes known as the 8VSB standard or the 8VSB modulated RF signal. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has mandated that each television channel have a bandwidth of 6 MHz whether the channel be a DTV channel or an NTSC channel. The FCC mask 110 requires that all signals broadcasted have their power attenuated starting at frequencies no greater than ±3.5 MHz relative to the center frequency Fc of the assigned channel. The attenuation is complete. The FCC mask, as shown in FIG. 5, requires that the attenuation be continuous within the mask. The mask has left and right skirts 112 and 114 that extend in a linear fashion from mask edges 116 and 118 from the in-band power level 120 to −64 dB at ±9 MHz relative to the center frequency Fc. The in-band power level 120 will sometimes be referred to herein as the reference level.

The filter 100, in accordance with the present invention, complies with and falls within the mandated FCC mask as is indicated herein by the solid line 130 representing the filter mask of filter 100. This shows the amplitude response of the filter. The vertical dashed lines 140 and 142 represent the 6 MHz bandpass from −3.0 to +3.0 MHz relative to the center line frequency Fc that must be passed by the filter. Attenuation of signals beyond ±3.0 MHz up to about ±3.45 MHz, as indicated by the dashed lines 144 and 146, is achieved by the filter 100. This attenuation is uniform about the center frequency extending downward to an attenuated level as indicated by the horizontal dashed line 148 and this attenuated level is at about −1 to −18 dB from the in-band power level 120. From this attenuated level, the amplitude response is further attenuated in a skirt like fashion to a level 150 of about −40 dB to −64 dB at ±9 MHz relative to the center line frequency Fc.

There may be some amplitude ripple at the in-band power level 120, however, this should stay within a response window 152 and not exceed about −0.5 dB below the in-band power level 120. Additionally, the insertion loss 154 should not exceed about −0.20 dB from the in-band power level 120.

Reference is now made to FIG. 6 which presents a graphical illustration of time with respect to frequency showing the group delay as represented by curve 200 within the 6 MHz bandpass as represented by vertical dashed lines 202 and 204 at −3.0 and +3.0 MHz relative to the center frequency Fc. Points A and B are taken at −2.69 and +2.69 MHz relative to the center frequency Fc as indicated by the vertical dashed lines 206 and 208. These lines 206 and 208 intersect curve 200 at points A and B which are to be kept within 50 nanoseconds of each other.

The specifications of the filter 100 as presented in FIGS. 5 and 6 and as discussed above have been presented relative to the standards in the United States wherein the FCC has allocated television channels as being 6.0 MHz wide. The European and other non-U.S. standards differ somewhat and, for example, the bandpass filter must be modified to pass frequencies on the order of 6 to 8.0 MHz which is the channel width or bandwidth in other parts of the world. Consequently, if the bandwidth of each channel is designated as being on the order of W MHz, then W may be 6 for the United States and 6 to 8 MHz for other parts of the world.

The filter described herein with respect to FIGS. 4, 5 and 6 may be employed as a stand alone mask filter with deep levels of IMD sideband rejection on the channel edges. Such a stand alone mask filter is illustrated in FIG. 4 and the operation is described herein in greater detail with reference to FIG. 27. Such a stand alone mask filter enhances transmitter performance by reducing the linearity requirements to meet the FCC mask and allows higher power transmitter operation for improved power output. As such the filter provides greater out-of-channel protection to guard against potential NTSC interference which, in many cases, could be the same NTSC station due to current adjacent channel allocations.

Additionally, the filter 100 as described relative to FIGS. 4, 5 and 6, may be employed in conjunction with another filter in a stand alone filter mask in the manner as set forth in FIG. 7. There, a pair of filters 100A and 100B, of identical construction to each other and to filter 100, are interposed between a left hybrid 300 and a right hybrid 302. The filters 100A and 100B are tuned to pass the frequency channel of the DTV signal. The left hybrid 300 has an input port 304 connected to a load 306 and a second input port 308 that receives an amplified DTV signal from an amplifier 310. The DTV signal enters the hybrid 300 and is split into two paths, one extending through the filter 100A and the other passing through filter 100B. The two signals enter the right hybrid 302 where they combine and provide a DTV signal at the output port 312 for application to an antenna or load 314. Another port on the right hybrid 302 is connected to a load 316. As will be discussed in greater detail hereinafter with reference to FIG. 27, such a circuit will easily meet the FCC sideband suppression levels while allowing operation of the transmitter at a substantially higher power level. This will be discussed in greater detail hereinafter with reference to FIG. 27.

Attention is now directed to FIG. 8 which illustrates a constant impedance filter-combiner 400 constructed in accordance with the present invention and employing a pair of filters 100C and 100D each constructed in the same manner as filter 100. Each filter 100C and 100D is tuned to pass television RF signals within a particular channel while rejecting all other RF frequencies. In the example being presented, the mode of operation is for the N+1 case. Consequently, the DTV signal is from a channel of higher frequencies than the NTSC signal. For example, the DTV channel may be that for channel 10 (192 MHz to 198 MHz) and NTSC channel may be channel 9 (186 MHz to 192 MHz). In this example, both filters 100C and 100D are tuned to pass the DTV signal (channel 10) while rejecting all other RF frequencies. The DTV signal is supplied to a power amplifier 402 and, thence, to an input port 404 at the left side of a hybrid 406. Another input port 408 of hybrid 406 is connected to a reject load 410. The DTV signal enters the hybrid 406 at the input port 404 and then is split into two portions which are respectively passed by the filters 100C and 100D and enter a right hybrid 414 and are recombined and are supplied to an output port 416. The NTSC signal, including both audio and video components, is supplied to a port 418 on the right side of hybrid 414. The signal is then split in the hybrid 414 and portions exit from the left side of hybrid 414 and are reflected from the filters 100C and 100D and reenter the hybrid 414 and recombine along with the recombined DTV signal and are provided at output port 416 and applied to a load, such as antenna 420. The hybrids in FIGS. 7 and 8 may be zero degree or ninety degree hybrids.

The filter-combiner presented in FIG. 8 requires only two hybrids and only two input ports (404 and 418) as opposed to the construction of the prior art filter-combiner in FIG. 2 that requires four hybrids and three input ports. Moreover, by providing such sharp tuned filters as filter 100C and 100D, there is no need to provide AURAL notches such as AURAL notches 50 and 52 in the prior art filter-combiner of FIG. 3.

FIGS. 9 and 10 illustrate radiation patterns of amplitude with respect to frequency for the N+1 case and the N−1 case, respectively. Thus, in the N+1 case as shown in FIG. 9, the NTSC signal is in the lower frequency channel, such as channel 9, and the DTV signal is in the adjacent higher frequency channel. This is a spectrum analyzer presentation and it shows low DTV power which is normal.

The filter-combiner of FIG. 8 may also be employed in the N−1 case, as shown in FIG. 10, such as wherein the DTV signal is the lower channel, such as channel 10, and the NTSC signal is in a higher channel, such as channel 11 (198 MHz to 204 MHz). Both FIGS. 9 and 10 show the radiation patterns as measured and each division in the vertical direction represents 10 dB and each division in the horizontal direction represents 2 MHz.

Reference is now made to FIG. 11 which illustrates a combiner 400′ which is virtually identical to combiner 400 and consequently like components are identified with like character references. The significant difference is that this combiner combines two DTV signals, one represented as D1 which is applied through amplifier 402 to the input port 404 of the left hybrid 406 in the same manner as discussed hereinbefore with reference to FIG. 8. In the case of FIG. 11 the DTV signal D1 passes through the hybrids 406 and 414 and the filters 100C and 100D as indicated by the dashed lines in the same manner as the discussion presented above with reference to FIG. 8. The filters 100C and 100D are tuned to pass only the DTV signals in the channel for the digital signal D1 (channel 10 192 MHz to 198 MHz) and reject all other frequencies. The second digital signal D2 may be from an adjacent channel which is either higher or lower than that of channel 10. In the event that it is of a higher frequency then it will be from channel 11. Since the filters 100C and 100D are tuned to reject such frequencies, the signal D2 will be split as it enters the right hybrid 414 and the split portions are reflected from filters 100C and 100D and pass back through the hybrid, as indicated by the dotted lines and combine with the digital signal D1 for application to the antenna or load 420. An amplitude versus frequency spectral plot for typical adjacent DTV channels is illustrated in FIG. 12.

Reference is now made to FIG. 13 which is similar to FIGS. 8 or 11 in that it employs a filter-combiner 400′ and may operate in an N+1, N−1 or a D+D configuration. As illustrated, a DTV transmitter 423 with an exciter 419 supplies a digital signal D1 to input port 404 and either an NTSC signal or a second DTV signal is supplied to input port 418 and the output is obtained from output port 416 and supplied to an antenna 420. An adaptive feedback path 417 provides feedback to the DTV exciter 419. A digital filter 421 at the input to the exciter 419 removes any interference that may be obtained from the NTSC signal or the second DTV signal. The exciter includes pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects the information signal supplied to antenna to correct for any distortion caused by the filters in the combiner-filter 400′. The pre-correction may be for both non-linear and linear distortions. Preferably the correction is for at least any linear distortion introduced by the filters in the filter-combiner 400′. As shown, the correction may be adaptive with a feedback path. The correction may also be non-adaptive, without the feedback path.

Reference is now made to FIG. 14 which illustrates another embodiment of the invention similar to that with reference to FIG. 13 and which may be used when transmitting two DTV signals referred to herein as signals D1 and D2. For purposes of illustration assume that D1 is the lower frequency signal and D2 is the higher frequency signal. This embodiment employs a pair of exciters 500 and 502 which supply the D1 and D2 signals to a pair of amplifiers 564 and 506. The amplified D1 and D2 signals are supplied to a filter-combiner, such as combiner 400′ from FIG. 11. The D1 signal is supplied to input port 404 and the D2 signal is applied through the filter 508 and thence to input port 418. The filter 508 is employed for passing the D2 signal and rejecting all other RF signals and then the signal is applied to the filter-combiner. The output signal which includes the combined D1 and D2 signals is supplied from the output port 416 to the antenna 420. In this embodiment, a sample is taken of the output signals D1 and D2 and fed back to the exciters 500 and 502 with the use of a signal splitter 510. Each of the exciters is provided with a filter to remove interference from the non-related exciter. Thus exciter 500 is provided with a filter 512 to remove any interference from signal D2. Exciter 502 is provided with a filter 514 to remove any interference from signal D1. Both exciters 500 and 502 include pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects the information signal supplied to antenna to correct for any distortion caused by the filters in the combiner-filter 400′. The pre-correction may be for both non-linear and linear distortions. Preferably the correction is for at least any linear distortion introduced by the filters in the filter-combiner 400′. As shown, the correction may be adaptive with a feedback path. The correction may also be non-adaptive, without the feedback path.

FIGS. 15 through 23 illustrate many of the features of the response characteristics of the filter described herein. These are specifically related to operation of the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 8 when operating with adjacent channels in an N+1 case.

FIG. 15 illustrates the response curve between the NTSC and the DTV passband zones. The sharp tuned characteristic is evident in the very close frequency spacing. Note the video frequency points marked as A, B and C. Point A is the chroma carrier at 3.58 MHz above the visual carrier, point B is the video upper band edge at 4.2 MHz above the visual carrier which is attenuated only −0.4 dB and point C is the reference visual carrier and shows little attenuation at the upper sideband frequencies around the chroma zone.

FIG. 16 illustrates the DTV bandpass showing useful in-band zone covering an inner span of 5.9 MHz. The amplitude response just beyond 5.9 MHz shows a rapid down turn in the response as the effect of the filter becomes apparent. This is a very sharp roll off and is beneficial for removing out of band IMD distortion products.

FIG. 17 is a graphical illustration of time with respect to frequency illustrating a typical group delay response of the DTV bandpass of the filter herein.

FIG. 18 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the video response of the filter relative to the lower adjacent channel (NTSC) and shows little attenuation at the upper sideband frequencies around the chroma zone.

FIG. 19 is a graphical illustration of time with respect to frequency showing the group delay characteristics of the lower adjacent channel.

FIG. 20 is a graphical illustration of amplitude with respect to frequency and shows the improved isolation needed for satisfactorily combining NTSC and DTV signals.

FIGS. 21, 22 and 23 illustrate audio performance aspects of the sharply tuned filter.

FIG. 21 is a graphical illustration of amplitude versus frequency and the monaural bandwidth and which is expanded from that illustrated herein at FIG. 15.

FIG. 22 shows the stereo bandwidth.

FIG. 23 is a graphical illustration of time with respect to frequency showing the typical group delay characteristics of the audio path in the filter-combiner herein.

FCC Mask Compliance

The FCC rules state, in part, “in the first 500 kHz from the authorized channel edge, transmitter emissions must be attenuated no less than 47 dB below the average transmitted power”.

Reference is now made to FIG. 24 which illustrates a typical DTV transmitter spectral spread known in the prior art. The total integrated power between the vertical dotted lines 600 and 602 is the reference power for determining if the −47 dB requirement is met in the adjacent 0.5 MHz zones.

FIG. 25 illustrates the 0.5 MHz zone 604 of the typical DTV transmitter spectral spread illustration of the prior art. It is to be noted that spectral spread illustration of FIG. 25 is without the employment of a sharp tuned filter, such as filter 100 described herein with reference herein to FIG. 4 as well as with reference to the other versions illustrated in FIGS. 7, 8, 11, 13 and 14. To the contrary, the illustration in FIG. 25 is representative of the prior art and it is clear that this does not meet the FCC −47 dB requirement.

Attention is now directed to the graphical illustration in FIG. 26 of amplitude with respect to frequency showing the spectral spread when the sharp tuned filter 100 described herein is employed. At the location of the FCC 0.5 MHz adjacent zone 604, the power is −51 dB below the in-band power level 610. Clearly, this shows FCC mask compliance as more than the −47 dB level has been met noting specifically location 612 in the illustration of FIG. 26.

Moreover, it is noted from FIG. 26 that the filter herein provides significant reduction of out of band spectrum components.

Power Enhancement

Reference is now made to FIG. 27 which illustrates at curve 614, the IMD (intermodulation distortion) sideband suppression characteristic without employing the sharply tuned filter herein. Curve 616 illustrates the sideband suppression characteristic with the sharp tuned filter herein when an IOT transmitter is operating at about 30% above normal power readings (note that the in-band power level 610′ in FIG. 27 is about 30% greater than in-band power level 610 in FIG. 26).

Reference is now made to FIG. 28 which is similar to FIG. 4, but includes an adaptive feedback path 700 and a DTV exciter 702. The exciter 702 includes a pre-corrector circuit 704 that pre-corrects the information signal supplied to antenna or load 106 to correct for any distortion caused by the filter 100. The pre-correction may be for both non-linear and linear distortions. Preferably the pre-correction is for at least any linear distortion introduced by the filter 100. As shown, the pre-correction may be adaptive with a feedback path. The pre-correction may also be non-adaptive, without the feedback path. The pre-correction should compensate for any linear distortion, such as any ripple in the in-band power level 120 in FIG. 5 caused by filter 100 during such higher power operation noted in the waveform of FIG. 27.

Summation

-   1. A sharp tuned bandpass filter (STF) is a key element in a TV     combining system for adjacent channel allocations where special     techniques are required to combine very closely spaced channels.     Current industry techniques use a set of notch diplexing cavities on     the NTSC aural carrier in a constant impedance configuration to     combine adjacent, upper or lower, DTV channels with an NTSC channel.     The filter-combiner described herein at FIG. 8 uses a set of sharp     tuned filters to do a very effective job of combining the NTSC and     DTV signals with significantly enhanced performance on the NTSC. -   2. The NTSC aural performance is improved with nearly double the     bandwidth of the notch cavity diplexing approach. This avoids     sideband cutting of the “PRO Channel” and group delay and amplitude     distortion of the SAP and BTSC Stereo subchannels. The notch     diplexing approach introduces an “S” curve in the group delay     response which makes it very difficult to correct. In addition, the     amplitude response is sloped off in an asymmetrical manner further     complicating the overall correction of the aural carrier. The sharp     tuned filter herein eliminates “S” curve response problems with a     soft group delay response that in many cases doesn't need correction     or very little of it. -   3. Video performance is enhanced with very little amplitude     distortion and only mild group delay distortion which can be easily     corrected. This is unlike the notch diplexing system that requires     amplitude and delay correction circuits to restore the severe     amplitude roll off of the 4.2 MHz burst flag due to the notch     cavities. The sharp tuned filter system needs only modest group     delay correction to restore the 12.5T pulse performance that can be     easily accomplished with existing analog circuits. -   4. The DTV to NTSC isolation characteristic is significantly     degraded in the notch cavity system which causes high frequency     bleed through of DTV components into the NTSC channel. The sharp     tuned filter system described herein does not have this problem and     provides a flat, uniform isolation value of about −35 dB over the     video band. -   5. The specified response and attenuation values shown herein     provide the necessary symmetry in the DTV channel for elementary     adaptive group delay and amplitude response correcting circuits to     achieve automatic adaptive correction without losing control. The     symmetry issue as specified is an important issue to reach the     standard accepted error vector magnitude for DTV transmission. -   6. The sharp tuned filter approach can combine adjacent channel DTV     signals. -   7. The attenuated point at +/−0.25 MHz off the upper and lower edge     of the filter provides additional attenuation to meet the FCC out of     band mask when the transmitter power is increased to a point where     the spectral spread shoulder level can be as great as −30 dB. Full     mask compliance can therefore be obtained when the DTV transmitter     is operated at higher than normal power levels for enhanced     efficient operation. The sharp tuned filter herein provides this     characteristic. The benefit of higher power operation while     maintaining FCC mask compliancy is a significant advantage. -   8. The sharp tuned filter system with the attenuation specification     shown herein exceeds the current FCC mask requirements and provides     further sideband reduction for noticeably improved interference free     operation on adjacent NTSC channels. -   9. The system design concept of using a sharp tuned filter system     for the unique application of adjacent upper or lower DTV channel     combining with an NTSC station, only recently allocated by the FCC,     with the performance as stated above. -   10. A sharp tuned filter system causes very little group delay and     amplitude errors over the video pass band and in particular, has a     very smooth response curve over the aural pass band to maintain good     BTSC performance and low synchronous AM. -   11. The filter-combiner herein can combine adjacent DTV channels. An     adaptive system can be connected to the system for adaptive     correction on each independent DTV path. A special filter in the     adaptive sample back line can be used in the exciter to filter out     the adjacent DTV interference for excellent dual DTV transmission. -   12. The filter herein, however, does restrict the 8VSB bandwidth     slightly which is a benefit for reduced adjacent channel     interference but does not cause any reduced performance on DTV     receivers. There is no measurable change in DTV receiver threshold     levels, hence no coverage loss. Transmitter EVM performance remains     excellent.

From the above description, those skilled in the art will perceive improvements, changes and modifications. Such improvements, changes and modifications within the skill of the art are intended to be covered by the appended claims. 

1. A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having only two inputs that respectively receive an NTSC combined visual and aural signal and a DTV signal wherein said NTSC signal and said DTV signal are in adjacent channels, said DTV signal being of greater frequency than said NTSC signal, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; and, said combiner having sharp tuned filtering means interposed between said inputs and said output and tuned to pass and not reflect said DTV signal while reflecting and not passing substantially all of said NTSC signal such that said passed DTV signal and said reflected NTSC signal combine as said combined output signal.
 2. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 1 in combination with an NTSC source that provides said NTSC signal and a DTV source that provides said DTV signal, said DTV source including an exciter having pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects said DTV signal to compensate for any distortions introduced by said filtering means.
 3. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 2 wherein said pre-correction circuitry compensates for any linear in-band distortions.
 4. A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having two inputs that respectively receive an NTSC combined visual and aural signal and a DTV signal wherein said NTSC signal and said DTV signal are in adjacent channels, said DTV signal being of greater frequency than said NTSC signal, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; said combiner having sharp tuned filtering means interposed between said inputs and said output and tuned to pass said DTV signal while reflecting substantially all of said NTSC signal such that said passed DTV signal and said reflected NTSC signal combine as said combined output signal; the bandwidth of each said channel is on the order of W MHz; and, said filtering means exhibits an amplitude response within a mandated mask such as that when operated in an RF transmitter the amplitude of the response is attenuated uniformly about the center frequency of said DTV channel within a frequency range of about ±0.5 W MHz to a maximum of about ±(0.5W+0.45) MHz and extending to an attenuated level of about −1 to −18 dB from the in-band power level.
 5. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 4 wherein W is in the range from about 6.0 MHz to about 8.0 MHz.
 6. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 4 wherein W=6.0 MHz.
 7. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 6, wherein said mandated mask is the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mask.
 8. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 7 wherein said mandated mask requires that the amplitude response be at ±3.5 MHz about said center frequency at the in-band power level and extend therefrom in a skirt like fashion to a level of about −64 dB at ±9.0 MHz.
 9. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 8 wherein the amplitude response of said filtering means extends from said attenuated level to a level of about −40 dB−64 dB at about ±9.0 MHz within said mandated mask.
 10. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 9 wherein the amplitude response of said filtering means extends from said attenuated level in a skirt like fashion.
 11. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 10 wherein said skirt like fashion varies in a linear manner.
 12. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 9 wherein said filtering means exhibits the characteristic of maintaining the amplitude of any variations in the magnitude of said in-band power level within about 0.5 dB.
 13. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 9 wherein said filtering means exhibits the characteristic of maintaining any insertion loss within about −0.20 dB from said in-band power level.
 14. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 6 wherein said given frequency channel has a channel edge and that said filter exhibits the characteristic of attenuating any emitted power within 0.5 MHz from said channel edge by an amount greater than −47 dB below said in-band power level.
 15. A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having two inputs that respectively receive an NTSC combined visual and aural signal and a DTV signal wherein said NTSC signal and said DTV signal are in adjacent channels, said DTV signal being of greater frequency than said NTSC signal, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; said combiner including first and second hybrids and first and second sharp tuned filters, said filters being tuned to pass said DTV signal while reflecting substantially all of said NTSC signal; said first hybrid having an input port that receives said DTV signal and passes portions thereof to a pair of output ports of said first hybrid; said second hybrid has a port that receives said NTSC signal and passes portions thereof to a pair of output ports of said second coupler; and, said first filter being connected from one of said output ports of said first hybrid to one of said output ports of said second hybrid and said second filter being connected from the other one of said output ports of said first hybrid to the other one of said output ports of said second hybrid to thereby pass said DTV signal and reflect said NTSC signal such that said passed DTV signal and said reflected NTSC signal combine as said combined output at another port of said second hybrid, wherein said another port serves as said output of said combiner.
 16. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 15 in combination with an NTSC source that provides said NTSC signal and a DTV source that provides said DTV signal, said DTV source including an exciter having pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects said DTV signal to compensate for any distortions introduced by said filters.
 17. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 16 wherein said pre-correction circuitry compensates for any linear in-band distortions.
 18. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 15 wherein the bandwidth of each said channel is on the order of W MHz; and, each said filter exhibits an amplitude response within a mandated mask such that when operated in an RE transmitter the amplitude of the response is attenuated uniformly about the center frequency of said DTV channel within a frequency range of about ±0.5 W MHz to a maximum of about ±(0.5 W+0.45) MHz and extending to an attenuated level of about −1 to −18 dB from the in-band power level.
 19. A filter-combiner as et forth in claim 18 wherein W is in the range from about 6.0 MHz to about 8.0 MHz.
 20. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 19 wherein W=6.0 MHz.
 21. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 20 wherein said mandated mask is the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mask.
 22. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 21 wherein said mandated mask requires that the amplitude response be at ±3.5 MHz about said center frequency at the in-band power level and extend therefrom in a skirt like fashion to a level of about −64 dB at ±9.0 MHz.
 23. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 22 wherein the amplitude response of each said filter extends from said attenuated level to a level of about −40 dB−64 dB at about ±9.0 MHz within said mandated mask.
 24. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 23 wherein the amplitude response of each said filter extends from said attenuated level in a skirt like fashion.
 25. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 24 wherein said skirt like fashion varies in a linear manner.
 26. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 23 wherein each said filter exhibits the characteristic of maintaining the amplitude of any variations in the magnitude of said in-band power level within about 0.5 dB.
 27. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 23 wherein each said filter exhibits the characteristic of maintaining any insertion loss within about −0.20 dB from said in-band power level.
 28. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 23 wherein said given frequency channel has a channel edge and that each said filter exhibits the characteristic of attenuating any emitted power within 0.5 MHz from said channel edge by an amount greater than −47 dB below said in-band power level.
 29. A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having only two inputs that respectively receive a first DTV signal and a second DTV signal wherein said DTV signals are of different frequencies and in adjacent channels, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; and, said combiner having sharp tuned filtering means interposed between said inputs and said output and tuned for passing and not reflecting said first DTV signal while reflecting and not passing substantially all of said second DTV signal such that said passed first DTV signal and said reflected second DTV signal combine as said combined output signal.
 30. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 29 in combination with a first DTV source that provides said first DTV signal and a second DTV source that provides said second DTV signal, each said DTV source including an exciter having pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects its said DTV signal to compensate for any distortions introduced by said filtering means.
 31. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 30 wherein said pre-correction circuitry compensates for any linear in-band distortions.
 32. A filter-combiner for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having two inputs that respectively receive a first DTV signal and a second DTV signal wherein said DTV signals are of different frequencies and in adjacent channels, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; said combiner having sharp tuned filtering means interposed between said inputs and said output and tuned for passing said first DTV signal while reflecting substantially all of said second DTV signal such that said passed first DTV signal and said reflected second DTV signal combine as said combined output signal; and the bandwidth of each said channel is on the order of W MHz; and, said filtering means exhibits an amplitude response within a mandated mask such as that when operated in an RF transmitter the amplitude of the response is attenuated uniformly about the center frequency of said DTV channel within a frequency range of about ±0.5 W MHz to a maximum of about ±(0.5 W+0.45) MHz and extending to an attenuated level of about −1 to −18 dB from the in-band power level.
 33. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 32 wherein W is in the range from about 6.0 MHz to about 8.0 MHz.
 34. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 32 wherein W=6.0 MHz.
 35. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 34, wherein said mandated mask is the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mask.
 36. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 35 wherein said mandated mask requires that the amplitude response be at ±3.5 MHz about said center frequency at the in-band power level and extend therefrom in a skirt like fashion to a level of about −64 dB at ±9.0 MHz.
 37. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 36 wherein the amplitude response of said filtering means extends from said attenuated level to a level of about −40 to −64 dB at about ±9.0 MHz within said mandated mask.
 38. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 37 wherein the amplitude response of said filtering means extends from said attenuated level in a skirt like fashion.
 39. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 38 wherein said skirt like fashion varies in a linear manner.
 40. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 37 wherein said filtering means exhibits the characteristic of maintaining the amplitude of any variations in the magnitude of said in-band power level within about 0.5 dB.
 41. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 37 wherein said filtering means exhibits the characteristic of maintaining any insertion loss within about −0.20 dB from said in-band power level.
 42. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 37 wherein said given frequency channel has a channel edge and that said filter exhibits the characteristic of attenuating any emitted power within 0.5 MHz from said channel edge by an amount greater than −47 dB below said in-band power level.
 43. A filter for combining television signals from adjacent channels comprising: said combiner having two inputs that respectively receive a first DTV signal and a second DTV signal wherein said DTV signals are of different frequencies and in adjacent channels, and providing a combined output signal at an output of said combiner; said combiner including first and second hybrids and first and second sharp tuned filters, said filters being tuned to pass said first DTV signal while reflecting substantially all of said second DTV signal; said first hybrid having an input port that receives said first DTV signal and passes portions thereof to output ports of said first hybrid; said second hybrid has an input port that receives said second DTV signal and passes portions thereof to a pair of output ports of said second hybrid; and, said first filter being connected from one of said output ports of said first hybrid to one of said output ports of said second hybrid and said second filter being connected from the other one of said output ports of said first hybrid to the other one of said output ports of said second hybrid to thereby pass said first DTV signal and reflect said second DTV signal such that said passed first DTV signal and said reflected second DTV signal combine as said combined output at another port of said second hybrid, wherein said another port is said output of said combiner.
 44. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 43 in combination with an first DTV source that provides said first DTV signal and a second DTV source that provides said second DTV signal, said first DTV source including an exciter having pre-correction circuitry that pre-corrects said first DTV signal to compensate for any distortions introduced by said filters.
 45. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 44 wherein said pre-correction circuitry compensates for any linear in-band distortions.
 46. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 43 wherein the bandwidth of each said channel is on the order of W MHz; and, each said filter exhibits an amplitude response within a mandated mask such that when operated in an RF transmitter the amplitude of the response is attenuated uniformly about the center frequency of said first DTV channel within a frequency range of about ±0.5 W MHz to a maximum of about ±(0.5 W+0.45) MHz and extending to an attenuated level of about −1 to −18 dB from the in-band power level.
 47. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 46 wherein W is in the range from about 6.0 MHz to about 8.0 MHz.
 48. A filter combiner as set forth in claim 47 wherein W=6.0 MHz.
 49. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 48 wherein said mandated mask is the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mask.
 50. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 49 wherein said mandated mask requires that the amplitude response be at ±3.5 MHz about said center frequency at the in-band power level and extend therefrom in a skirt like fashion to a level of about −64 dB at ±9.0 MHz.
 51. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 50 wherein the amplitude response of each said filter extends from said attenuated level to a level of about −40 to −64 dB at about ±9.0 MHz within said mandated mask.
 52. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 51 wherein the amplitude response of each said filter extends from said attenuated level in a skirt like fashion.
 53. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 52 wherein said skirt like fashion varies in a linear manner.
 54. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 51 wherein each said filter exhibits the characteristic of maintaining the amplitude of any variations in the magnitude of said in-band power level within about 0.5 dB.
 55. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 51 wherein each said filter exhibits the characteristic of maintaining any insertion loss within about −0.20 dB from said in-band power level.
 56. A filter-combiner as set forth in claim 51 wherein said given frequency channel has a channel edge and that each said filter exhibits the characteristic of attenuating any emitted power within 0.5 MHz from said channel edge by an amount greater than −47 dB below said in-band power level. 